The Kitchen Bucket List

  • Air Fryer
  • Baking
  • BBQ
  • Griddle
  • About
  • Contact
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Air Fryer
  • Baking
  • BBQ
  • Griddle
  • About
  • Contact
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • search icon
    Homepage link
    • Air Fryer
    • Baking
    • BBQ
    • Griddle
    • About
    • Contact
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    Home » Griddle

    Caramelized Mushrooms

    Published: Jul 24, 2023 · Modified: Aug 8, 2023 by The Kitchen Bucket List

    Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

    Done on the outdoor griddle, Caramelized Mushrooms, are so easy to do. We add a pinch of garlic and some olive oil which gives a wonderful buttery and savory taste to the mushrooms.

    Done on the outdoor griddle, Caramelized Mushrooms, are so easy to do. We add a pinch of garlic and some olive oil which gives a wonderful buttery and savory taste to the mushrooms. this recipe
    Jump to:
    • Ingredients
    • Caramelizing Mushrooms
    • Substitutions
    • Variations
    • Equipment
    • Storage / Leftover / Rewarm
    • FAQ
    • Related
    • Pairing
    • Caramelized Mushrooms

    This post may contain affiliate links, please read the disclaimer policy.

    Done on the outdoor griddle, Caramelized Mushrooms, are so easy to do. We add a pinch of garlic and some olive oil which gives a wonderful buttery and savory taste to the mushrooms. We love how you can get everything done on the outdoor griddle. When you kick off with these caramelized mushrooms it is going to be a special meal. They caramelize up in 12 minutes. You can simply move them over to the side while you prepare burgers, chicken, or eggs.

    We love how you can get everything done on the outdoor griddle. When you kick off with these caramelized mushrooms it is going to be a special meal. They caramelize up in 12 minutes. You can simply move them over to the side while you prepare burgers, chicken, or eggs. If you made extra, no worries, just fridge them and use them the next day.

    Ingredients

    We used white mushrooms, salt, granulated garlic, and olive oil. That's it. We love how you can get everything done on the outdoor griddle. When you kick off with these caramelized mushrooms it is going to be a special meal. They caramelize up in 12 minutes. You can simply move them over to the side while you prepare burgers, chicken, or eggs. If you made extra, no worries, just fridge them and use them the next day.

    We used white mushrooms, salt, granulated garlic, and olive oil. That’s it.

    Head down to the recipe card for more detailed quantities.

    Caramelizing Mushrooms

    The big thing here is to warm up the griddle which gives you plenty of time to clean and prepare the mushrooms. If you are adding the mushrooms to something else, you will want to have that prepared as well.

    1. Prep Time – Clean the mushrooms and pat them dry with a towel then slice to your desired thickness. Place in a bowl and add the oil and mix. Then add the salt and granulated garlic to coat the mushrooms.

    2. Caramelizing Mushrooms – This is really straightforward, just flip every 1 – 2 minutes until you reach your preferred doneness.

    3. Wait or Serve – One of the things I love about the outdoor griddle is being able to keep items warm while I cook the next item. Simply shift the mushrooms to a side area with the burner off and make the next item to add the caramelized mushrooms too.
    Otherwise, they are excellent all by themselves, just place them in a bowl and enjoy.

    The recipe card has more detailed instructions and quantities.

    Caramelizing the mushrooms is really straightforward, just flip every 1 - 2 minutes until you reach your preferred doneness. To evenly caramelize the mushrooms, I take the time to ensure the end cuts are flat side down for the first part of the cook.
    Sprinkle is excited to share with you our Simple, Easy, and Tasty recipes. She has traveled for years and enjoyed food everywhere from Hawaii to Italy. Now she is the muse for The Kitchen Bucket List helping us developed and create our favorite dishes to bring to all of you.

    To evenly caramelize the mushrooms, I take the time to ensure the end cuts are flat side down for the first part of the cook.

    Substitutions

    You can substitute the white mushrooms with baby bells, Portabella, or Shiitake. The thickness and size will change the time, especially a Portabella.

    Variations

    Mushrooms are very versatile, so you can change the flavor to your preference. Remember that mushrooms will pick up the flavor easily, so a little goes a long way.

    • Extra Garlic– If you’re going to use a garlic clove, I’d chop or thinly slice it and add it at the beginning. I would do the same with fresh minced garlic.
    • Deluxe – Have some fun with some Italian seasoning and chives. You can finish the mushrooms with a bit of butter before you serve.
    • Earthy taste– You just need to add some rosemary.

    Equipment

    A good knife, a cutting board, and a griddle that’s all you need to caramelize the mushrooms.

    Scroll down to the recipe card for more equipment details

    Wait or Serve - One of the things I love about the outdoor griddle is being able to keep items warm while I cook the next item. Simply shift the mushrooms to a side area with the burner off and make the next item to add the caramelized mushrooms too. Otherwise, they are excellent all by themselves, just place them in a bowl and enjoy.

    Storage / Leftover / Rewarm

    • Storage: Place in an airtight container and place in the fridge. I prefer to use them in 1 – 2 days.
    • Leftovers: Don’t worry about doing too much. The following day they are great in a mushroom and cheese omelet.
    • Rewarm: I like to put them back on the griddle or skillet. You can add a dash of oil or a bit of butter. Just flip over low heat for a few minutes until hot again.

    FAQ

    Can I substitute the granulated garlic?

    Yes. Garlic powder or dry minced will work like granulated. If you choose fresh be careful not to let it burn. You may need to flip the mushrooms a bit more while they caramelize.

    What is the difference between caramelizing and sautéing the mushrooms?

    The difference is “low and slow” versus “hot and fast”, respectively. Caramelizing is cooking at a low temperature to allow the sugars to be more prominent. Sautéing is done at a higher temperature. It is quicker and develops more of a crust or even a char to the mushrooms.

    Can you freeze the caramelized mushrooms?

    You sure can. Make sure they have cooled off and place them in an airtight freezer bag with as much of the air removed as possible.

    Related

    Looking for other tasty side dishes? Try these:

    • Seasoned air fryer gnocchi coming out of the air fryer in the basket with a beautiful golden color.
      Air fryer gnocchi
    • Smashed Baby Dutch Yellow potatoes with Colby Jack cheese melting while they crisp up.
      Smashed potatoes with cheese
    • Overhead shot of the French onion baked potatoes. The melted Gruyere cheese has crisped on the side of the potatoes sitting in the air fryer basket.
      French onion baked potatoes
    • Serving scalloped potatoes from the air fryer with a spoon. The side dish has a cheesy-crunchy crust.
      Air Fryer Scalloped Potatoes with a twist

    Pairing

    Here are some dishes you can add the caramelized mushrooms too:

    • Searing a smoked ribeye with the smokers flame broiler. This recipe can be done on a charcoal BBQ too.
      Smoked ribeyes with BBQ spice rub
    • Sliced smoked meatloaf with BBQ sauce that has caramelized to form a crust. It is moist and tender.
      Smoked meatloaf recipe for the BBQ or smoker
    • The smoked meat being sliced on a cutting board.
      Smoked corned beef brisket
    • Two smoking beef short rib racks resting vertically on a BBQ grill grate.
      Smoking beef short ribs
    Welcome to The Kitchen Bucket List. My name is Karina and I am very excited to share with you our Simple, Easy, and Tasty recipes. After years of cooking and baking with my girls, where even dad shows up from time to time, especially for the BBQ, The Kitchen Bucket List was created in the Spring of 2020.

    What did you have with the caramelized mushrooms?
    Let us know in the comments, below.

    Done on the outdoor griddle, Caramelized Mushrooms, are so easy to do. We add a pinch of garlic and some olive oil which gives a wonderful buttery and savory taste to the mushrooms. We love how you can get everything done on the outdoor griddle. When you kick off with these caramelized mushrooms it is going to be a special meal. They caramelize up in 12 minutes. You can simply move them over to the side while you prepare burgers, chicken, or eggs.

    Caramelized Mushrooms

    The Kitchen Bucket List
    It just takes under 20 minutes to have buttery garlic caramelized mushrooms on your burger, chicken sandwich, or what about an omelet?
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe Save Saved!
    Prep Time 10 minutes mins
    Cook Time 12 minutes mins
    Total Time 22 minutes mins
    Course Side Dish
    Cuisine American
    Servings 4 Portions

    Equipment

    • Griddle
    • Knife
    • Cutting board
    • 2 Griddle Spatulas
    • BBQ tongs
    • Griddle scraper (Optional)

    Ingredients
      

    • 8 oz. white whole mushrooms
    • 1 tablespoon olive oil
    • ½ teaspoon granulated garlic
    • ⅛ teaspoon salt

    Instructions
     

    Prep Time

    • Preheat the griddle on low for 5 minutes.
    • Clean the white mushrooms and pat them dry with a towel. This helps the seasoning adhere to the mushrooms for the flavor you want.
    • Slice them into quarters or to your preferred thickness.
    • Place the mushrooms in a bowl and add the oil and mix. Then add the salt and granulated garlic to coat the mushrooms.

    Caramelizing Mushrooms

    • We have a 36-inch griddle with 4 burners. I turn off the first two burns and use the other half of the griddle for caramelizing the white mushrooms.
    • I like to sear the mushrooms for 4 minutes on one side first.
    • Then I flip them every 1 – 2 minutes until a subtle golden color or your preferred doneness. It was about 12 minutes in total for this cook.

    Wait or Serve

    • Once the caramelized mushrooms are at your level of doneness you can simply shift the mushrooms to a side area with no heat to wait. Then make the next item to add the caramelized mushrooms too.
    • Lucky you if you are enjoying them as is. I may have grabbed a couple before I put them on our burgers. Just place them in a bowl to serve and Enjoy!
    Keyword Caramelized, Caramelized Mushrooms, garlic, Garlic Mushrooms, Griddle, mushrooms

    HAPPY GRIDDLING!!!

    Griddle recipes

    • Holding a piece of the crispy bacon chicken ranch quesadilla with meted cheese and a drip of ranch dressing coming from the middle. It is ready to be eaten.
      Bacon chicken ranch quesadilla
    • A chicken crunchwrap sliced into 3 pieces and stacked on a cutting board. You can see the crispiness of the tortilla and the freshness of the ingredients.
      Chicken crunchwrap
    • Holding the Philly cheesesteak hot and fresh right above the griddle. It has melted provolone, grilled onions and peppers, and a hot dog bun grilled to perfection.
      Philly cheesesteak on the griddle
    • Five nearly seared wagyu beef sliders with bacon and grilled onions on top. They are sizzling on the griddle.
      Wagyu beef sliders on the griddle
    FacebookTweetPinLinkedIn

    Filed Under: Cooking, Griddle, Outdoor Cooking, Recipes, Side Dish

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    I'm Karina,

    After years of cooking and baking with my girls, where even dad shows up from time to time, especially for BBQ. The Kitchen Bucket List was created.
    I hope you enjoy these Simple, Easy, and Tasty Recipes with your friends and family.

    More about me →

    Recent Recipes

    • Either for feeding a hungry crowd or meal planning for a busy week, this fast and fresh griddle ground beef fried rice is ready in 30 minutes. The fried rice is ready to serve from the griddle.
      Griddle fried rice
    • Holiday rice krispie treats with the addition of pumpkin spice. It gives the classic treat a wonderful cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger flavor. The perfect treat to enjoy from Halloween to Christmas.
      Holiday rice krispie treats
    • Overhead shot of the piggies in a blanket in the air fryer basket. They are done up for Halloween to look like mummy dogs with googly eyes.
      Piggies in a blanket air fryer (Halloween edition)
    • Halloween cinnamon rolls shaped like intestines on a black plate with toy spiders. The red icing adds the perfect touch of gore.
      Halloween cinnamon rolls

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    Recipes

    Air Fryer

    Baking

    Griddle

    BBQ

    About

    About
    The Kitchen Bucket List

    Contact

    Modern footer. Welcome to The Kitchen Bucket List's Recipes & About footer. My name is Karina and I am very excited to share with you our Simple, Easy, and Tasty recipes. After years of cooking and baking with my girls, where even dad shows up from time to time, especially for the BBQ, The Kitchen Bucket List was created in the Spring of 2020.

    Privacy Policy - Disclaimer - Terms and Conditions - Website Accessibility Statement

    Copyright © 2025 | The Kitchen Bucket List